• Dr. Josh

The Business Case for Talent Management: and Holocracy

The dynamics inherent in contemporary business operations foster an ongoing need for creating a competitive advantage, and harnessing the talent required to actualize the organization’s objectives (Silzer & Dowell, 2010).

Most business leaders understand the importance of integrating talent management with business strategy, human resource (HR) strategy, and the culture of the organization (Silzer & Dowell, 2010), although this may be much harder to do in practice.

Peer-reviewed literature on talent management has yet to solidify a single operational definition for talent management, which can encompass the culture, operations, and processes of a given firm in the design and implementation of current and future business objectives through the attraction, development, positioning, and retention of talent (Silzer & Dowell, 2010).

In the business world, several benefits are said to exist with firms that invest in a culture high in trust, including improved financial performance and decreased turnover, above and beyond firms that do not implement the same investment in workplace culture (Great Place to Work Institute, 2015).

The following takes a look at an online company,, to investigate the implementation of a new governing structure called Holocracy, and how the company is maintaining their spots in the Fortune 100 and 100 Best Companies to Work For (Fortune, 2015) through their philosophies and tactics for managing talent.

Holocracy and the 10 Core Values of is an online store founded in 1999, operating since 2009 as a subsidiary of, Inc. (Bloomberg Business, 2015), who reportedly maintains the company with a “hands-off policy” (Fortune, 2015).

The subsidiary continues to show an increase in profit margins for the past seven years ranking #35 this year on the Fortune 100 list, with over 1,400 employees averaging over $80,000 per year for salaried workers, including paid time off for holidays, vacation, and sickness, offering eight, twelve, and five days respectively (Fortune, 2015).

In 2014, transitioned its traditional organizational structure into a Holocracy (Denning, 2014), a comprehensive management paradigm that radically changes organizational structure, managerial decision-making, and distribution of power (HolacracyOne, 2015).

Holocracy uses circles of power empowered by openness, and democratic procedures dictated through a comprehensive Holocracy Constitution (Denning, 2014; HolacracyOne, 2015).

This inward-looking process is said to work well for, a company renown for its obsessive focus on the customer value proposition (Denning, 2014), with a tagline, “powered by service” (, 2015), which can be witnessed in the firm’s ten core values aligned with all business strategies, branding, and culture (Zappos Insights, 2015) extrapolated upon in Table 1, after which three of these values will be examined to show how is practicing this touted alignment.

Table 1

The 10 Core Values of (taken from Zappos Insights, 2015)


Value Subcomponents

Deliver WOW Through Service Differentiation, innovation, emotional impact, going beyond expectations, word-of-mouth valance

Embrace and Drive Change Preparation for constant change, not accepting the status quo, bottom-up change

Create Fun and a Little Weirdness Unconventionality, humor, no extrem- ism, interesting actions, consistency, authenticity, diversity

Adventurous, Creative, & Open-Minded Daring but not reckless, taking risks, following gut instincts, creativity, adventure, freedom

Pursue Growth and Learning Challenging stretch goals, unlocking potential, problem solving, expertise, adaptation

Build Open and Honest Relationships Trusting and faithful relationships with all stakeholders, compassion, communication, loyalty, embracing diversity

Build a Positive Team & Family Spirit Diversity in ideas, friendly and exciting atmosphere, leading by example, collaboration, eliminating negativity, positive interaction

Do More with Less Continuous improvement, operational excellence, sense of urgency, mistakes as learning

opportunities, exceeding high standards

Be Passionate and Determined Perseverance, vision, excitement, inspiring others, optimism, realistic attitudes, sense of urgency

Be Humble Respectful of others, doing things from the heart, not being selfish, celebrating individuality, no

arrogance, moral character, a quiet confidence


Aligning Corporate Values to Talent Management Processes

The success of a talent management system hinges on being integrated with, and supported by, a strategic business plan and becoming the cultural mindset of the firm (Silzer & Dowell, 2010). takes its fifth core value, “pursue growth and learning,” and aligns this with their mission to develop future industry leaders, thus fostering a Pipeline Department tasked with developing leaders from within the organization, dictated by the given department’s progression plan and business needs (Zappos Insights, 2015b).

The seventh core value, “build a positive team and family spirit,” is aligned to a Goals Department, where coaching opportunities and workshops are offered to both employees and their family members, including a recognition celebration for all who reach their goals (Zappos Insights, 2015b).

The ninth core value, “be passionate and determined,” is aligned to the firm’s Onboarding process, where all new hires receive the same four weeks of training regardless of position or function, with a combination of technical and cultural training, and a graduation ceremony held upon completion (Zappos Insights, 2015b).

These examples provide evidence for’s pervasive mindset in integrating its talent management procedures throughout all corporate strategies, its culture, operations, and HR planning initiatives, perhaps giving the organization a firm grasp on gaining strategic competitive advantage (Silzer & Dowell, 2010).

Lessons Learned

The 100 Best Companies to Work For program has accumulated over 30 years of research pointing to firms on the list nearly doubling positive employee response, a 12-fold increase in profits, annualized stock returns increasing up to three times, significantly lowering turnover, and overall performance three times that of the general marketplace (Great Place to Work Institute, 2015).

This points to the notion that a highly robust workplace culture can create distinctive and tangible returns on investment (Great Place to Work Institute, 2015), something has been able to accomplish for several years by systematically focusing and integrating their talent management system into the very fabric of their strategies, operations, and culture (Fortune, 2015; Zappos Insights, 2015a; 2015b).

With the recent reorganization into a Holocracy, can be said to continuously seek out ways of encouraging and enabling their workforce to practice and internalize their ten core values and mission statement, in an effort to balance out their concentrated focus on delivering value to the customer while empowering employees to become self-directed in their work (Fortune, 2015; Denning, 2014).

Arguably, these results speak for themselves, creating evidentiary and logical justifications for organizations seeking out their own balance in creating comprehensively aligned talent management systems that deliver value to the customer and offer the firm a true competitive advantage.


Bloomberg Business (2015). Company overview of, Inc. [Online website.]. Retrieved from

Denning, S. (2014, Jan. 15). Making sense of Zappos and Holocracy. Retrieved from

Fortune (2015). 100 best companies to work for: [Online website.]. Retrieved from

Great Place to Work Institute (2015). What are the benefits? [Online website.]. Retrieved from

HolocracyOne, LLC (2015). Holocracy: How it works. [Online website.]. Retrieved from

Silzer, R. & Dowell, B.E. (2010). Strategy-driven talent management: A leadership imperative. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. (2015). About Zappos culture. [Online website.]. Retrieved from

Zappos Insights (2015a). The Zappos family core values: Core value document [Downloadable PDF.]. Retrieved from

Zappos Insights (2015b). Zappos department fact sheets [Downloadable PDFs.]. Retrieved from

#holocracy #talentmanagement #businessconsulting


© 2020 by Joshua Caraballo, Psy.D.


Pompano Beach, FL USA